Sounds like a good book. Provides a LOT to discuss as it would relate to real world situations.
Mac66 wrote: ↑Tue Jun 21, 2022 3:02 pm
It's about a guy who gets caught out on the road during an EMP and has to walk home from Tallahassee to Lake County Florida. Thought that was interesting considering I have place in the Villages. Thought of you Florida guys. It was written in 2013.
That's a pretty good walk. That part of Florida has a lot of rural and wooded areas. Not as built up as father south (Tampa, Orlando, Miami, Sarasota, Naples etc). Still resources but fewer and farther between. However, also a plus because there would be less people to encounter along the way than in the bigger cities. Of course the roads can be quite busy, particularly I-75 on that side of the state as well as I-10.
Mac66 wrote: ↑Tue Jun 21, 2022 3:02 pm
Got about a 60lb pack he intends to carry 230 miles. It includes hatchets, knives, radios, NVGs, batteries, tools and a shit ton of other stuff. Well okay.....we'll see.
Yep, that's going to get real old, real quick. Probably some stuff he really doesn't need.
Mac66 wrote: ↑Tue Jun 21, 2022 3:02 pm
- No fishing gear. Is there places to fish in Florida?
And some stuff he probably would have found useful. A fishing kit doesn't have to be big or bulky. Bob used a 'credit card' fishing kit on one of our SEP gatherings a few years ago and yes, he did catch a fish or two. That demonstrated itself to be a handy piece of gear that takes up practically no space/weight in a pack. Shane and I had the Popeil Pocket Fisherman and though it's bigger than what Bob had, still smaller than a rod and real. And they actually worked well. We caught fish as well. And Florida really has no shortage of fresh water practically everywhere. You'd generally be better off fishing for survival than hunting unless it's squirrels and such you're hunting. Fishing is stationary and takes little in the way of calorie expenditure. And you could have multiple lines in the water in close proximity for an increased change of catching calories.
Mac66 wrote: ↑Tue Jun 21, 2022 3:02 pm
Carries an XD45 (not a bad choice) he also has 3 extra 13 round mags and a couple boxes of ammo
No, not a bad choice. Not the best choice either. A good 45acp always makes a decent option but that ammo is heavy compared to other service calibers. Three mags and a couple of extra boxes is some poundage that has to be lugged around. My thoughts would be a Glock in 9mm. That isn't brand-loyalty, just practicality. Glock has proven itself as a battlefield capable weapon which means sweat, hot, cold, grime, dust, snow and wet. And 9mm simply because it's the most used caliber (service caliber) thus probably a lot easier to find/scrounge.
Actually, my own thoughts are a Glock 35 with 40S&W, 357sig and 9mm barrels. I don't have a 357sig barrel (yet) for mine but it's not a pressing concern because the caliber isn't really all that popular (in terms of being easily available). But nice to have and a barrel takes up little space/weight and uses the same mag as 40S&W. And although 40's have fallen from on high, they are still out there and second only to the 9mm generally in availability. So I'd rather have three possible calibers in one platform than one option only.
Mac66 wrote: ↑Thu Jun 23, 2022 8:28 am
However, it is thought provoking in that it makes you think about what you would have in your get home bag including what kind of guns. The main character doesn't have/use a long gun until Super Prepper gives him an M1 Carbine.
That begs the question...Should you have a long gun in your vehicle for getting home? I carry a 12 ga shotgun and a box of shells in my truck. Is that enough gun/ammo? Would a 10/22 with a couple hundred rounds be better? How about an AR15? Will I ever walk* 200 miles to get home?
So keeping with my line of thinking on the G35 above, my choice is a Sub 2k in 9mm. Uses the same mags as Glock plus it folds up small to fit in a pack or sling bag so you can remain gray man and not attract attention.
A SG isn't a bad choice either. Positives are that ammo can be used from birds to bears as well as defense. A pump or even single-shot isn't a bad choice and you've got some nice setups. Is it an AR-15 to deal with the roving hoards that roam the pages of paperbacks? No. But it has some practical options. Downside is size/weight of the ammo that has to be lugged around.
I really like my Sub 2K plan.
Mac66 wrote: ↑Tue Jun 21, 2022 3:02 pm
He's walking. Apparently bicycles don't exist in Florida. Instead of walking 1-2 miles an hour with a 60 lb pack, he could have easily gotten at least 10 miles an hour on a bike. Presumably going 10 times as fast means you won't be out there near as long and don't need as much stuff. It's not hard to ride 20, 30 or even 40 miles a day. I don't think it would be hard to ride 60 miles in 8 hours stopping to rest along the way. Heck, I've ridden 100 miles in 8 hours. Granted I was lightly loaded and in really good shape at the time. On the other hand I was 62 when I did it. A younger person could go faster and farther than that.
-Even if he couldn't find a bike, a garden cart or dolly would have made his journey easier.
A bike is always a good option. Fairly quiet and can get you there quicker than the shoe leather express. And they make folding bikes that I've looked at before. Even considered a scooter (the kind you push with one foot or gas/electric). Folks use them to commute all the time and lots of folks feel they work well. If it's motorized it can keep going even if you're tired. Drawbacks of course but offers positives as well and can fold up a bit for vehicle storage.
Mac66 wrote: ↑Tue Jun 21, 2022 3:02 pm
I'm about 1/3 of the way through it so have a ways to go yet. It does get me thinking about re-evaluating my own get home bag.
Something to hold and filter water. Something to start a fire. Something to shed the rain or give relief from the sun. Something to replace spent calories. A boo-boo kit.
Things to consider in Florida is the weather. Yes, it gets hot and humid. Today as an example it was in the 90's with a heat index of 105 with 65% humidity. That is NOT going to be fun walking in with a pack on your back. And if it's spring/summer you're likely to get rained on in the afternoon. Often a downpour. Staying dry will be a big consideration.
Let us know how the book continues
